The Commodification of Freedom in the Age of Neoliberalism


Dhaka Papers graphics
Isolation produced by the loss of public spaces is repackaged as a lifestyle in those private spaces. “Community” becomes a brand instead of a basic human necessity. The more people crave belonging and fear missing out on those spaces, the more valuable these commercial spaces become and the more public space gets devalued.
In the age of neoliberalism, freedom is less about something we are denied and more about something we are sold. At a time when the world is falling back into its repeated history of fascism and far-right uprisings, freedom can only be found in fewer spaces. But it comes at the cost of belonging, having a price tag.
The middle class deals with a much more illusionary version of freedom because, despite systemic barriers and inequality, there is a common belief that if they try hard enough, they can attain freedom. To understand how freedom is sold, we need to understand what freedom means to those who reside within this belief. Growing up, our primary institutions of belonging are our families, schools and, debatably, the internet. With time, we diverge from our parents, teachers, neighbours and internet strangers on topics like how one should eat, how one should act according to one's gender and sexuality, and how one should pursue one's life—the list is endless. And conflict arises when homes and institutions draw inflexible boundaries around our choices in the name of social, religious and cultural norms. In a neoliberal society, these “norms” are the accessories to the capitalist system. Against this, freedom is, among many other things, being able to say “no” and knowing that one will be safe despite the expectations and coercion acting in support of “yes”.
If we want our institutions to let this version of freedom be exercised in our spaces, it rarely comes without the cost of social ostracisation. But we have learnt how to create it for ourselves in the form of friendships, trusted partnerships and fictive relationships of “boro apa / bhaiya”—people we keep close. These relationships cost nothing. These people are the only few spaces where we can exercise our freedom, although not to the fullest extent, with more room than what the institutions around us allow.
But we need a place to let these relationships happen. We need a place where we can catch up with an old friend after an exhausting 9-to-5 in peace and relaxation. Friendships need a place where people won't be asked to leave after they’ve finished their meals. And this is where things get complicated. Public places in our cities aren't perfect. Parks are policed and are never equally safe for women and queer people. But they are at least free to enter, and there is very little chance that you will be asked to leave because other people need to sit in your place. Now, even that imperfect option is disappearing as the city loses more tea stalls to coffee franchises and open fields to gated communities. Parks are neglected or handed over to corporations, reflecting decisions made by states and developers that treat open ground as wasted ground. Here, the neoliberal state decides which things deserve to stay free.
The market fills the gap when a teenager in Dhaka has nowhere to go that isn’t their home or school. People's resorts, where they can take a break from the world, gradually become restaurants, coffee shops or community events that charge 500 Tk for entry. These places market the safety, ambience and relaxation that any citizen has the right to claim from their local parks and fields. A “worthy” customer is someone who is dressed according to their aesthetics, and coffee isn't the only thing on their menu. These places also sell an experience of freedom, and having a place to be with your community to attain some sense of belonging becomes a marketing strategy. Those who can afford the commute and food get a conditional version of it.
But those who can't are pushed back into their homes, institutions or online spaces, where whatever little freedom they could have experienced with their community gets lost. They are pushed back to the very places where they are still negotiating their “no” in the first place. The relationships they forge might cost nothing, but the places where they happen have a price. So, belonging and having some room to experience being yourself and being free become matters of money.
Recognising this problem, many community events for young adults and teenagers are taking place in the city, such as slam poetry nights, stand-up comedy sessions, movie screenings and informal book clubs, where people can meet, engage and be a part of the community. But many of these events require entry fees, with the total cost often exceeding 500 Tk. How accessible are these events for young people if simply entering a place costs that much or more? It’s true that organising these events requires capital, but it is also important to notice the fact that communities now have an entry fee. When belonging is priced, social life starts mirroring the market: scheduled and transactional. We meet people we can afford to meet in places we can afford to enter. It promotes the idea that, to be part of a community, the first step is to gain the ability to afford it. It ignores the fact that companionship, community and the need for belonging are primal and extremely crucial for human life. Because of this overwhelming desire to be able to afford community, we begin to understand ourselves as individuals first and as members of anything second. The loneliness that follows is said to be a personal failure, but it is the only reasonable and predictable consequence of this system.
Ironically, this system also sells back the cure. Isolation produced by the loss of public spaces is repackaged as a lifestyle in those private spaces. “Community” becomes a brand instead of a basic human necessity. The more people crave belonging and fear missing out on those spaces, the more valuable these commercial spaces become and the more public space gets devalued. The cycle is enforced again, and the next generation starts with even fewer rooms than we did.
Does this mean that the people who try to organise ticketed community events for a genuinely good cause, or the people who love to hang out at cafes, are perpetrators of the neoliberal system? Probably not, at least not consciously. Does it mean that relationships have stopped mattering? No, but relationships have become harder to reach for and maintain. This means that what freedom used to mean has now extended beyond people to spaces as well: being able to purchase access to a place where people who let your “no” be as it is will exist. This conveys that our existence can be priced as well, and that is warning enough for us to start pursuing the fight for more free rooms, fields, benches and tea stalls—the corners that aren't advertised as aesthetic or dimly lit.
__________________
Writer: Undergraduate student, University of Dhaka
Your contribution keeps investigative journalism fearless, transparent, and accessible to everyone. To support us securely donate from anywhere.



