Subah-dar Mamata: Who Opened the Gates of West Bengal for BJP’s Taking

আরিফুজ্জামান তুহিন
Arifuzzaman Tuhin
Published: May 9, 2026 at 06:29Click to change
Subah-dar Mamata: Who Opened the Gates of West Bengal for BJP’s Taking

Sketch: AI

Share:

The fall of the Trinamool Congress (TMC) in West Bengal exposes an uncomfortable truth many in India’s liberal establishment refused to acknowledge for many years, crushing the Left Front in West Bengal and replacing material politics with identity politics only exposed the eroding resistance against Hindu Nationalism and it cleared the road for the inevitable fall of one of the last cultural and liberal bastions.

On 22 February 2012, in the Dewandighi area of Bardhaman city, Pradip Tah, a former legislator and leader of Communist Party of India (Marxist) and Kamal Gayen a senior leader of the same party was allegedly beaten to death by TMC cadres during a procession by the Leftists in West Bengal. This was just one incident of political murder and wider landscape of terror that became dominant feature of oppression against the leftists as CPI(M)-led Left Front rule ended in West Bengal in 2011.

For years, India’s liberal establishment sold a comforting fiction about West Bengal. Mamata Banerjee, they insisted, was the final barricade against the BJP and the RSS, Durga who would reverse the rise of Hindu Nationalism in India and will crash them in a Epic Battle between the Good and Ashu. She was portrayed as the secular counterweight to Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalism, impulsive perhaps, theatrical certainly, but ultimately indispensable in the struggle against the far right.

That myth deserves a political burial

The rise of the BJP in West Bengal did not happen despite Mamata Banerjee’s rule. It happened through it. To understand this, one must return to the blood-soaked years that followed the fall of the 34-year-old Left Front government in 2011. What unfolded after that election was not merely a transfer of power. It was a campaign of political annihilation.

The day after Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharjee resigned, across West Bengal, from West Midnapore to Bankura, from Murshidabad to Hooghly Leftists activists were hunted down, burned alive inside their homes, hacked to death, driven from villages, stripped of livelihoods, and erased from local political life. Hundreds were killed. Tens of thousands were displaced. Thousands of party offices were seized. And yet, through much of this period, India’s mainstream liberal discourse remained astonishingly selective in its outrage.

Because the violence was directed not at liberals, but at the Leftists and the Communists

For fifteen years, the principal target of TMC’s machinery was never the BJP. It was the Leftists, especially the CPI(M), whose labour unions, peasant organizations, and student movements remained the only structured political force capable of sustained street mobilization. There was always a coordinated “Stop the Leftists” project. There was never a serious “Stop the BJP” project. In fact, the opposite occurred.

While liberals celebrated Mamata Banerjee as a secular icon, the ideological and organizational ecosystem of the BJP quietly expanded across Bengal under her watch. RSS-affiliated educational institutions such as Saraswati Shishu Mandir and Saraswati Vidya Mandir multiplied throughout the state. These schools are not politically neutral institutions; they are long-term ideological factories designed to normalize Hindu majoritarianism from childhood.

Under Leftists’ rule, such expansion had been tightly resisted. Under Mamata Banerjee, it flourished. The BJP did not build Bengal’s communal infrastructure alone. It inherited a political terrain that had already been prepared for it. This is the central contradiction liberal commentary continues to evade: authoritarian populism does not defeat the far right by destroying the democratic Leftists. It clears the road for it.

The tragedy of West Bengal is that an entire anti-Leftists coalition, liberals, sections of civil society, anti-communist activists, fragments of the radical Leftists, opportunistic intellectuals, even some former Leftists sympathizers united to dismantle the CPI(M), imagining this would somehow deepen democracy. Instead, they demolished the only mass political structure capable of resisting Hindu nationalism at scale.

The irony is brutal

Many of the smaller anti-Leftists forces that once aligned, directly or indirectly, with TMC politics have now vanished into political irrelevance. Congress has withered. SUCI(C) has disappeared from public consciousness. Various ultra-Leftists factions that once viewed the CPI(M) as the “primary enemy” have either collapsed organizationally or become electorally invisible.

The CPI(M), despite years of repression, still retains trade unions, student movements, peasant organizations, and a political cadre structure. *The others are gone and this matters beyond Bengal* Across the world, liberal politics increasingly mistakes symbolism for resistance. Grand gestures replace structural politics. Public religiosity is marketed as secularism. Spectacle substitutes organization.

And Mamata Banerjee mastered this performance


She attended iftar gatherings draped in oversized veils, performed carefully staged displays of religiosity, and projected herself as the defender of minorities; even while simultaneously enabling the growth of the very communal ecosystem that strengthened the BJP politically.

Identity politics and theatre became a substitute for material politics

Meanwhile, unemployment deepened, corruption scandals exploded, and public faith in institutions collapsed. Recruitment scandals involving school jobs, once a lifeline for Bengal’s educated middle and lower-middle classes, exposed an entrenched patronage system tied directly to TMC networks.

The result was politically predictable: disillusionment, institutional decay, polarization, and the steady normalization of the BJP. And yet, even now, many commentators continue framing every criticism of TMC as an indirect service to Hindu nationalism. This logic has become one of the great intellectual failures of contemporary Indian liberalism. Because when every critique of authoritarian regional populism is dismissed as “helping the BJP,” democratic accountability itself disappears.

West Bengal now stands at the endpoint of that politics

The old narrative “Vote for TMC to stop BJP” is collapsing under the weight of its own contradictions. Increasingly, many voters have come to believe the opposite: that TMC’s politics prolonged and legitimized the BJP’s growth. For the Leftists in India, paradoxically, this may create strategic clarity. For years, it faced a two-front battle: BJP at the national level, TMC at the state level. Now the lines are starker. The adversary is politically aligned in outcome, even when rhetorically opposed in style.

None of this means the BJP represents a lesser danger. Quite the opposite.

Hindu majoritarianism remains the single greatest threat to India’s democratic future. But defeating it requires honesty about how it grows and one of the most uncomfortable truths in Indian politics is this:

"Mamata Banerjee was never the barricade against the BJP."

She helped build the road it walked in on.

__________________________

Author: Editor, Dhaka Papers

Email: [email protected]

Support Independent Journalism

Your contribution keeps investigative journalism fearless, transparent, and accessible to everyone. To support us securely donate from anywhere.

Secure Payment GatewaybKash • Nagad • Rocket • Debit & Credit Cards • Net Banking
Share: